24/09/2026 0 Comments
What should we say?
What should we say?
# Reflecting on the Scriptures

What should we say?
Our readings this week are 1 John 5:6-12 and Matthew 21.23-32.
We live in a world in which it can be very difficult to know who and what to trust when it comes to understanding the world around us and forming our opinions.
Things are decried as being 'fake news' when they're politically unhelpful. Falsehoods can be generated with ever increasing levels of convincing detail by Artificial Intelligence. Influencers make their money by telling us that this is the best hair cream that they've ever used (they're obsessed with it!). Musicians get stood down for daring to express a political opinion on stage.
Behind all of these things, there is often an agenda, personal, political, or commercial, and that muddies the waters.
We might think this is a new thing, but the readings in front of us this week tell us quite patently that it's not. For as long as human beings have been around, it seems, we've been playing these games.
Jesus, in this snippet from Matthew's Gospel, encounters the chief priests and the elders. They want to know, I think, what his agenda is, what his purpose is, where he will align himself in the greater picture. "By what authority," they ask him, "do you do the things that you are doing?"
It's a question that asks him to make a claim about himself-his relationship with God, his relationship with the people, his relationship with the political authorities around him. To reveal a little something of what's in it for him - personal, political, or commercial...
But Jesus turns the question on them. "I'll tell you," he says, "if you tell me what you think of the baptism of John. Was it of human origin, or was it from heaven?"
We can only imagine that that was a hot topic of conversation at the time: this crazy man out in the desert being claimed as a prophet, and yet being denied by the authorities. Who was right? Who was wrong?
They go away and have a little huddle, checking with each other,
"If we say it's from heaven, he'll only ask us, 'Why didn't you believe him?' But if we say it's of human origin, well, we're terrified of this crowd, for they all think John was a prophet."
Crucially they are asking one another, not "What do we think?", but, "What should we say?" And in that they reveal the truth about themselves: appearance is more important than substance. They are veneer right through to the centre.
So they answer Jesus, "We do not know" - not because they don't know, but because they don't want to commit.
At that point, the conversation with him comes to a close.
It didn't have to. They could have said almost anything else. This wasn't a question that needed a right answer, it just needed an honest one. Whichever side they'd come down on, they could have found themselves in a deepening relationship with Christ. They could have even stayed honestly on the fence - the only place they couldn't be was hiding behind it. They had to own who they were. But they are so worried about the consequences of being truthful - what the crowd will think, what Jesus will say, what position they will be left occupying - that they lose the capacity simply to stand in front of him and say what they believe.
And perhaps that is where this passage gets uncomfortably close to home.
Because we live in a world where we are constantly encouraged to have an answer, to take a position, to know which side we are on. And we live in a world where those answers are given at the cost of judgement, of reviews, and of likes. We learn to curate what we say according to the audience in front of us. We learn to manage our opinions, our image, even sometimes our faith.
Jesus doubles down. He goes on to tell a story about two sons: one who agrees to help his father and then doesn't, and one who refuses to help his father and then does. It's a story, again, about revealing who we actually are, and that at times being a different - and far more important thing - than what we appear to be.
Jesus seems to be asking for something much simpler, and much harder: that we be truthful, that we dare to share with him who we actually are, and what we actually believe, and put our trust in the extraordinary promise that despite (because of) all that, he loves us, and he'll still be there to carry on the conversation.
That can be a frightening place to inhabit. If we stop curating our image, and managing our answers, we end up being honest with ourselves as well. And might not always like what we find.
But remember this: he doesn't ask us to be right, or impressive, or even certain. Just truthful. He can work with that, and he can draw out the beautiful that is - I promise you - there.
Then perhaps we will begin to find we're in a conversation in which we learn not only about ourselves, but about a God who - as St. John points out - is only ever truthful about who they are, because the Spirit is truth.
This may well be the very definition of faith. Not having the right answer, but having the courage to be honest enough to let God meet us where we actually are, and listening to the truth he speaks over, and through, us.
Comments